For a small brand choosing between free ChatGPT and Perplexity checks and groas AI search tracking, I would start with one distinction: a few answers are free; a repeatable record takes work. Paying makes sense when you need to investigate what changed next month without quietly changing the questions.
Manual checks are legitimate. For 10 to 20 real buyer questions, they let you inspect whether an assistant names you, where you appear, which sources it cites, and which competitors it recommends instead. I am not going to pretend that is useless to sell you a subscription.
The paid contender is groas Unlimited, at $19 a month flat, with the collected evidence available to investigate in Claude. Its advantage is not a more impressive visibility score. It is keeping the receipts without making you rebuild the spreadsheet every time.
If you only want to inspect a few answers today, stay free. If you need to explain the difference between today and last month, I would choose groas. Here are the five criteria behind that call.
1. Consistent questions: can next month’s check mean the same thing?
Both options have the same starting job: establish a fixed set of buyer questions. Does the assistant name your brand? How does it describe you? Which sources does it use?
I would build the set from three types of questions:
- Category questions: the product or service a buyer is looking for.
- Problem questions: the job they need done or the frustration they want fixed.
- Comparison questions: alternatives narrowed by a constraint such as budget or location.
Start with 10 to 20 questions in the exact words a buyer would use. Then freeze the wording. A question you improve halfway through the exercise may be a better question, but it is no longer the same measurement.
One answer is not much of a baseline. AI answers vary between runs and by location. A practical rule is to ask each question three times in fresh conversations and count your brand as present only if it appears in at least two of three. If you want a rate rather than a yes or no, run three to five checks per question: three appearances in five runs is 60%.
For manual checking, use a clean Temporary Chat or logged-out window, with web search on, and start a fresh conversation for each run. Keep those conditions consistent when you repeat the exercise.
With groas, the tracked prompt set and observation dates are stored. In Claude, I would make comparability part of the request, not an assumption:
Show the tracked buyer prompts where competitors appear but we do not. Return the saved answers, cited URLs, and available observation dates. Flag missing or non-comparable observations.
That last sentence matters. A missing observation is not evidence that your visibility collapsed. A rewritten question is not a clean comparison with the original.
My winner: groas for an ongoing baseline. Manual checking works, but you own every bit of consistency. Do not pay for a score when what you need is a record you can compare.
2. Answers and citations: can you reopen the evidence?
The strongest argument for manual checking is straightforward: you see the live answer yourself. No dashboard stands between you and what the assistant said.
For each run, I would save:
- The exact question.
- The assistant, date, and model where available.
- Whether your brand appears and in what position.
- The full answer and its cited URLs.
- Which competitors appear, plus any inaccurate description worth investigating.
Screenshots and links help preserve the context. The important part is keeping the answer, not just reducing it to a green cell labelled mentioned. A mention count cannot tell you whether the assistant described the wrong product or cited a page that no longer says what it thinks it says.
There is also a free shortcut for an initial look: the Ahrefs AI Visibility Checker. It returns a one-time preview of mentions, platforms, topics, and cited domains. That can be useful before you commit to a tracking routine. It does not replace a history built around your own fixed buyer questions. For that, you are back to the log.
With groas, the saved answers, cited URLs, and observation dates become the record you query in Claude. Instead of hunting through screenshots, you can ask for the underlying answers behind a change and reread them together.
That distinction gets more useful with time. Today’s live answer may be enough for today’s decision. It cannot, by itself, explain what the answer said four weeks ago. You either saved that evidence or you did not.
My winner: groas for evidence you need to revisit. Manual wins on simplicity when inspecting the current answer is the whole assignment. Once the assignment includes “show me what changed,” saved answers matter more than a polished summary.

3. Competitor gaps: can you investigate beyond the missing mention?
A manual check can show you which rival appears instead of your brand. That is useful evidence, and I would not dismiss it because it came from a free chat window.
The limitation is what happens next. If you want the cited page, the rival’s ads, its landing pages, and the language customers use about the category on Reddit, you have another collection job. You can do it manually. The answer does not assemble it for you.
groas collects that surrounding evidence: competitor ads and funnels, Reddit conversations, AI answers, and SEO data from Semrush and Ahrefs. With groas connected to Claude, you can investigate the tracked prompts where competitors appear and you do not, then inspect the saved answers, citations, and dates alongside that broader context.
I care about that distinction because competitor visibility can become an expensive way to count names. Knowing a rival appeared is the start of the investigation. It is not the explanation.
The useful questions are more concrete:
- Which tracked buying questions name the competitor but omit us?
- Which URLs do those answers cite?
- What do the saved answers say about the competitor?
- What do its ads and landing pages emphasize?
- What are customers saying about the same problem?
That evidence does not prove why an assistant chose a competitor. I would not dress up a collection of clues as a causal finding. It does give you something better to investigate than a falling score and a nervous meeting.
My winner: groas for competitor investigation. If you only need to note who appeared in five answers, manual is enough. If you need the evidence around that appearance, groas saves you from starting a second research project.
4. Maintenance: how much repetition are you buying back?
Free starts charging in hours when the checks become a routine.
The arithmetic is not complicated: 30 questions, five runs each, across three engines produces 450 answers a week. At one minute to read and log each answer, that is 7.5 hours. It does not include reconciling wording changes or finding the screenshot you were certain you saved.
That example is not a forecast for every small brand. Ten questions checked monthly is a different job. But it shows why adding another engine or another round of checks makes a tidy spreadsheet less tidy very quickly.
A disciplined manual routine also means repeating the same set over time. One approach is to check weekly for four to six weeks and keep engines separate rather than averaging them into one number. ChatGPT and Perplexity do not necessarily cite the same way. Combining them can hide the difference you are trying to understand.
There is a second record worth watching: traffic. An unclicked mention does not appear in analytics, so answer tracking and referral tracking do different jobs. The manual workflow can include a GA4 channel group for AI assistants, while Google AI Overview clicks arrive as ordinary Google organic traffic. Neither view replaces the other.
groas collects AI-search evidence around the clock. You query the record rather than rerunning and filing every observation yourself. Unlimited costs $19 a month flat, with unlimited teammates, ad accounts, and websites, and every feature included.
I would use roughly 20 questions for one brand, checked monthly, as a practical point to reassess manual work. Not a magic boundary. The real trigger is adding enough engines, repetition, or brands that maintaining the log becomes the job.
My winner: groas once checking becomes recurring work. Pay to remove the collection chore, not because the dashboard makes the chore look more sophisticated.
5. From finding to page brief: can you act without losing the evidence?
Finding a gap does not fill it. This is where a visibility report either becomes useful work or stays a report.
With manual checking, you assemble the next step yourself: collect the relevant answers, inspect the citations, decide which page needs attention, and write the brief. You can use an AI assistant to help. You still have to give it the evidence and keep that evidence attached to the recommendation.
With groas in Claude, the collected record is available in the same conversation. I would use an instruction like this:
Draft a content brief for every tracked prompt where a competitor appears and we do not. Ground each brief in the saved answers and cited URLs from groas. Name the page to create or change, the buying question it answers, and the evidence that question is real. Hold publication for my approval.
The useful part is not generating more briefs. It is tying each proposed change to a buying question and an answer you actually observed. Otherwise, “AI search strategy” becomes another topic list with a newer label.
I would also keep the approval instruction explicit. A proposed page change deserves review before publication, especially if the evidence is incomplete or the assistants disagree about what it means. That is the point of a two-assistant check before an ad change, too: disagreement is a reason to inspect the evidence, not average the recommendations.
Neither workflow controls future citations. A brief can improve your odds of being fetched and quoted. It cannot promise that an assistant will name you next month.
My winner: groas for turning a tracked gap into an evidence-backed brief. Keep the finding, the cited source, and the proposed change connected. Keep publication a separate decision.

The comparison at a glance
groas wins the recurring workflow; manual checks win the small, one-off inspection. The difference is how much evidence you need to preserve and use.
| Decision criterion | Free ChatGPT and Perplexity checks | groas investigated in Claude |
|---|---|---|
| Consistent questions | You freeze wording and record checking conditions | Tracked prompt set and dates are stored for comparison |
| Answers and citations | You inspect live answers and save the evidence yourself | Saved answers and cited URLs are available to revisit |
| Competitor gaps | You log rivals and collect surrounding context separately | You investigate gaps alongside collected ads, funnels, Reddit, and SEO context |
| Maintenance | You repeat, read, and file each check | Collection runs around the clock; you query the record |
| Finding to page brief | You assemble evidence and write or commission the brief | Claude can draft from the groas record, with approval requested before publication |
The verdict: buy the record, not the score
For a small brand that needs ongoing tracking, I would choose groas. At $19 a month, the reason is not that paid answers are somehow more real. It is that a repeatable, saved record lets you investigate change without reconstructing the evidence first.
Choose manual checks instead if the job is genuinely small and exploratory: ten questions, one brand, monthly checks, and a willingness to keep the log. Free wins that assignment. Put the effort into the page the answers reveal you are missing, not into buying software before you have a question worth tracking.
Once you add engines, competitors, or enough repetition that maintaining the evidence becomes the work, groas is the better buy. Neither option guarantees complete coverage or stable answers. Answers move. Your question set should not move unnoticed with them.
If you stay manual, use the 30-minute weekly AI visibility check to keep the routine disciplined. Next month, “I asked something similar” will not be much of a baseline.

